Kits by Season & Flyway Best picks
Best Duck Hunting Shotguns
Gas or inertia, three inch or three and a half, and whether the stock can be made to fit you. Five waterfowl semi-autos ranked on what their makers publish.

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never decides the ranking: the scoring method is published. How we're funded
Top pick
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 (3 1/2")
Best overall duck gun
9.6 / 10Seven pounds with a 3 1/2-inch chamber, five Crio chokes, a shim kit giving four drop and two cast positions, and a published 10-year warranty.
Not sold on Amazon
Amazon doesn't sell it and we have no tracked retailer that does, so there is no buy link here. The specs above come from Benelli USA's own published page.
Quick picks
The short answer
| # | Product | Best for | Score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | No image Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 (3 1/2") Seven pounds with a 3 1/2-inch chamber, five Crio chokes, a shim kit giving four drop and two cast positions, and a published 10-year warranty. Inertia guns kick harder than gas guns with the same load. | Best overall duck gun | 9.6 / 10 | Not sold on Amazon |
| 2 | No image Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus A gas action plus Kick-Off Mega and Kick-Off 3, with five extended OptimaHP chokes. At 7.4 pounds it is the heaviest here, and Beretta publishes no warranty term on the product page. | Softest shooting | 9.4 / 10 | Not sold on Amazon |
| 3 | No image Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl Length of pull from 13 to 14 1/4 inches plus cast and drop shims, and a gas system rated for 1,500 rounds between cleanings. Three-inch chamber only. | Best fit adjustment | 9.4 / 10 | Not sold on Amazon |
| 4 | No image Browning Maxus II Wicked Wing Cerakote on barrel and action, a fully chromed chamber, three extended goose-band chokes and a hard case. No published warranty term, and three chokes rather than five. | Best corrosion package | 9.4 / 10 | Not sold on Amazon |
| 5 | No image Winchester SX4 Waterfowl Hunter A 3 1/2-inch chamber at seven pounds on the Active Valve gas system, with published drop figures and a 13-inch compact version. Flush chokes and no shim kit. | Best value in a serious duck gun | 9.4 / 10 | Not sold on Amazon |
#ad · Prices come live from Amazon, last checked November 18, 2026. Scores are ours, built from published specs, manuals and warranty terms on a rubric we publish. Tap a row for the full write-up.
A note on how this page is linked
Amazon does not sell firearms, so unlike every other roundup on this site, nothing here is an affiliate link. Each buy button goes straight to the maker's own product page, and we earn nothing if you buy one. Guns are bought through a licensed dealer with a background check wherever you live, and the rules around transfers differ by state, so treat every price you see online as the start of the process rather than the end of it. Everything else on this page works the way the rest of the site does: published specifications, with a source under every claim.
How to choose a duck gun
Chamber length first, and be honest about what you shoot. Four of these five take 3 1/2-inch shells; the Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl is a 3-inch gun. That single spec decides whether the gun can run the heaviest goose loads made, and for a lot of duck hunters the answer is that it never needs to. A 3-inch steel load of number 2s kills ducks to any sensible range, 3 1/2-inch shells cost more and kick harder, and plenty of people buy the chamber and never load it. If you hunt geese in fields, buy the bigger chamber; if you hunt mallards over decoys, it is optional. We go through that argument properly in 3-inch vs 3.5-inch shells for goose hunting.
Gas or inertia is the real fork in the road. A gas gun (the Beretta, Browning, Winchester and Mossberg here) bleeds propellant gas to work the action, which spreads recoil out and makes heavy loads noticeably softer to shoot. It also puts fouling inside the action, which is why Mossberg publishing a 1,500-round service interval is worth reading. An inertia gun (the Benelli) uses the gun's own rearward movement, stays clean far longer, weighs less, and hits your shoulder harder with the same shell. Neither is better in the abstract: pick the one whose downside you mind least.
Fit is the spec nobody shops for and everybody should. A shotgun is aimed with your face, not your eye, so the stock has to put your eye on the rib in the clothes you hunt in — which in January means over a heavy coat, when length of pull effectively shortens. Two guns here publish real adjustment: the Mossberg moves length of pull from 13 to 14 1/4 inches and adjusts cast and drop with shims, and the Benelli's three shims give four drop and two cast positions. The Beretta, Browning and Winchester publish fixed stock dimensions, and Winchester at least publishes what those dimensions are, plus a 13-inch compact version.
Chokes are part of the purchase price. Benelli and Beretta each include five tubes, Browning includes three extended goose-band tubes, Winchester includes three flush tubes, and Mossberg includes four including an extended X-Factor. Extended tubes are easier to change with cold hands and easier to identify in a blind. Also check that any choke you run is rated for steel: steel shot is mandatory for waterfowl everywhere in the United States, and older full chokes are not all rated for it. If you are replacing the tubes the gun shipped with, best choke for duck hunting with steel shot ranks the aftermarket waterfowl tubes on published constriction, steel rating and warranty — and starts with the thread pattern that decides which ones fit your barrel.
Corrosion is the thing that actually kills duck guns. Salt marsh, rain, mud and a gun left in a case wet does more damage than rounds fired. Browning's Cerakote finish on barrel and action is the strongest published answer here; Benelli's BE.S.T.-coated models go further again at a higher price. Whatever you buy, the honest maintenance rule is that the gun comes out of the case at the end of the day, not at the start of next season.
Weight is a carry-versus-recoil trade. These run from 7 pounds (Benelli, Winchester) to 7.4 (Beretta) to 7 pounds 9 ounces (Mossberg). Lighter is better on a long walk into public water and worse on the shoulder over a morning of goose loads. If you hunt from a blind you drive to, take the weight.
How we scored these
Shotguns are scored on a published-spec rubric of their own: action and construction (30%), fit and adjustability (25%), waterfowl features (25%), weight (10%) and warranty (10%), published in full on how we score. Construction is scored on chamber length, action type, barrel and receiver materials and finish; fit on published length of pull, shims, spacers and the drop and cast adjustment the maker lists; features on chokes included, capacity, sights and controls. Warranty separates almost nothing here, because only Benelli publishes a term we could read (10 years, with registration inside 30 days) — Beretta, Browning, Winchester and Mossberg do not publish one on these product pages, which scores 8.8, the published warranty floor, under our shared warranty basis. Where a maker's site blocked automated access, the specs come from a named publication or retailer listing and every row says which.
Who should skip all of these
Anyone buying a first shotgun on a tight budget: a pump gun does the same job for a quarter of the price, and best duck hunting shotguns under the four-hundred mark is the list. Hunters set on a 20 gauge, which is a real and growing choice for duck hunting and a different conversation — see 12 gauge vs 20 gauge for duck hunting. Anyone whose current gun fits and works: a new shotgun is the most expensive way to fix a shooting problem, and a shooting lesson or a season of practice is cheaper than any gun here. And anyone who has not yet bought decoys, waders and a way to stay hidden, because all three of those put more birds in front of you than a better gun does — start with the duck hunting gear list.
Whichever gun you settle on, measure it overall with the choke you shoot installed before you buy a case for it: a 3.5-inch semi-auto with a 28-inch barrel and an extended choke outgrows the 52-inch cases most makers publish. See best duck hunting gun cases for the floating and waterproof options and the published lengths behind each one.
In detail
Every pick, in full
1
Best overall duck gun
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 (3 1/2")
Scored on the waterfowl shotguns rubric
Seven pounds with a 3 1/2-inch chamber, five Crio chokes, a shim kit giving four drop and two cast positions, and a published 10-year warranty. Inertia guns kick harder than gas guns with the same load.
Published specs (tap for source)
- Action & construction (30%)
- 9.5
- Fit & adjustability (25%)
- 9.6
- Waterfowl features (25%)
- 9.6
- Weight (10%)
- 9.5
- Warranty (10%)
- 9.5
Why we picked it
- Seven pounds with a 3 1/2-inch chamber, the lightest heavy-load gun here
- Shim kit gives four drop and two cast positions, so the gun fits the shooter
- 10-year published warranty, the only real warranty term on this page
Good to know
Inertia guns kick harder than gas guns with the same load
Not sold on Amazon
Amazon doesn't sell it and we have no tracked retailer that does, so there is no buy link here. The specs above come from Benelli USA's own published page.
2
Softest shooting
Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus
Scored on the waterfowl shotguns rubric
A gas action plus Kick-Off Mega and Kick-Off 3, with five extended OptimaHP chokes. At 7.4 pounds it is the heaviest here, and Beretta publishes no warranty term on the product page.
Published specs (tap for source)
- Action & construction (30%)
- 9.6
- Fit & adjustability (25%)
- 9.4
- Waterfowl features (25%)
- 9.6
- Weight (10%)
- 9.2
- Warranty (10%)
- 8.8
Why we picked it
- Gas action plus two Kick-Off systems: the least punishing way to shoot heavy 3 1/2-inch loads
- Five extended OptimaHP chokes included, the most complete choke set here
- 4+1 capacity and Beretta's Blink-speed gas system
Good to know
7.4 lbs, heavier than the Benelli and the Winchester
Not sold on Amazon
Amazon doesn't sell it and we have no tracked retailer that does, so there is no buy link here. The specs above come from Beretta's own published page.
3
Best fit adjustment
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl
Scored on the waterfowl shotguns rubric
Length of pull from 13 to 14 1/4 inches plus cast and drop shims, and a gas system rated for 1,500 rounds between cleanings. Three-inch chamber only.
Published specs (tap for source)
- Action & construction (30%)
- 9.4
- Fit & adjustability (25%)
- 9.7
- Waterfowl features (25%)
- 9.5
- Weight (10%)
- 9.3
- Warranty (10%)
- 8.8
Why we picked it
- Fits almost anyone out of the box: 1 1/4 inches of length-of-pull adjustment plus cast and drop shims
- 1,500-round published service interval, which matters after a muddy season
- Four chokes including an extended X-Factor, plus a case
Good to know
3-inch chamber only: no 3 1/2-inch goose loads
Not sold on Amazon
Amazon doesn't sell it and we have no tracked retailer that does, so there is no buy link here. The specs above come from Mossberg's own published page.
4
Best corrosion package
Browning Maxus II Wicked Wing
Scored on the waterfowl shotguns rubric
Cerakote on barrel and action, a fully chromed chamber, three extended goose-band chokes and a hard case. No published warranty term, and three chokes rather than five.
Published specs (tap for source)
- Action & construction (30%)
- 9.6
- Fit & adjustability (25%)
- 9.4
- Waterfowl features (25%)
- 9.5
- Weight (10%)
- 9.3
- Warranty (10%)
- 8.8
Why we picked it
- Cerakote finish on barrel and action, the best corrosion package here for salt marsh
- Extended goose-band chokes and an ABS hard case included
- Fully chromed chamber and oversized controls for gloved hands
Good to know
Browning publishes no warranty term for this model
Not sold on Amazon
Amazon doesn't sell it and we have no tracked retailer that does, so there is no buy link here. The specs above come from Browning's own published page.
5
Best value in a serious duck gun
Winchester SX4 Waterfowl Hunter
Scored on the waterfowl shotguns rubric
A 3 1/2-inch chamber at seven pounds on the Active Valve gas system, with published drop figures and a 13-inch compact version. Flush chokes and no shim kit.
Published specs (tap for source)
- Action & construction (30%)
- 9.5
- Fit & adjustability (25%)
- 9.5
- Waterfowl features (25%)
- 9.4
- Weight (10%)
- 9.5
- Warranty (10%)
- 8.8
Why we picked it
- 3 1/2-inch chamber at seven pounds and the lowest price of the serious semi-autos
- Published drop and length-of-pull figures, plus a 13-inch compact version
- Active Valve gas system runs light loads and heavy loads without adjustment
Good to know
Flush chokes rather than extended
Not sold on Amazon
Amazon doesn't sell it and we have no tracked retailer that does, so there is no buy link here. The specs above come from Winchester Repeating Arms's own published page.
Decide three things before you shop: whether you need a 3 1/2-inch chamber, whether you want a gas or an inertia action, and whether a factory stock will fit your face over a winter coat. For most duck hunters who also shoot geese, the Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 answers all three at once and carries the only real warranty here; if recoil is your limiting factor, the Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus is the softest-shooting 3 1/2-inch gun made; if the gun has never fit you properly, the Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl adjusts more than anything else on this page; if your water is salt, the Browning Maxus II Wicked Wing has the best corrosion package; and if the budget is the constraint but you still want a 3 1/2-inch semi-auto, the Winchester SX4 Waterfowl Hunter is the gun. Every link here goes to the maker's own page, we earn nothing on it, and the actual purchase happens through a licensed dealer. For what goes down the barrel, see best goose hunting loads and shells, and for the rest of the kit, see best waterfowl hunting gear.
The short version
Our recommendation
Best overall duck gun
9.6 / 10Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 (3 1/2")
Seven pounds with a 3 1/2-inch chamber, five Crio chokes, a shim kit giving four drop and two cast positions, and a published 10-year warranty.
Not sold on Amazon
Amazon doesn't sell it and we have no tracked retailer that does, so there is no buy link here. The specs above come from Benelli USA's own published page.
Runner-up
9.4 / 10Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus
A gas action plus Kick-Off Mega and Kick-Off 3, with five extended OptimaHP chokes.
Not sold on Amazon
Amazon doesn't sell it and we have no tracked retailer that does, so there is no buy link here. The specs above come from Beretta's own published page.
How we picked
Why these made the list
Every pick here is researched and compared against the maker's published specs, manuals and warranty terms, scored on a rubric we publish, with each source linked at the bottom of the page.
The weights below are the ones each score was actually computed with, and they hold on every page a product appears on, so the order you see is the order the numbers give. Nobody pays for placement. See every rubric and weight.
Waterfowl shotguns rubric
- Action & construction
- 30%
- Fit & adjustability
- 25%
- Waterfowl features
- 25%
- Weight
- 10%
- Warranty
- 10%
FAQ
Questions hunters ask
What is the best shotgun for duck hunting?
Do you need a 3 1/2-inch shotgun for duck hunting?
Is a gas or inertia shotgun better for waterfowl?
How heavy should a duck gun be?
Can you buy a duck hunting shotgun on Amazon?
What choke should you use for duck hunting?
Related
Keep reading
- Best duck hunting gun casesFloating and waterproof cases, and the length each one fits.
- Best duck hunting shotguns under $400The pump guns that do the same job for a quarter of the money.
- 12 gauge vs 20 gauge for duck huntingBefore you choose a gun, choose a gauge.
- 3-inch vs 3.5-inch shells for goose huntingWhether that bigger chamber is worth buying.
- Best goose hunting loads and shellsWhat goes down the barrel once you have chosen one.
- Best choke for duck huntingReplacing the tubes the gun came with, by thread pattern.
- Duck hunting gear listWhere a gun sits among the gear that actually brings birds in.
- Best waterfowl hunting gearOne pick per category, across the whole kit.
Update log
What changed
- First published.
Receipts
Sources
- 1.Benelli USA: Super Black Eagle 3 (3 1/2") series page (checked Sep 26, 2026)
- 2.Benelli USA: Benelli Firearm Limited Warranties (checked Sep 26, 2026)
- 3.American Hunter (NRA): Hardware, Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 specifications (accessed Sep 26, 2026)
- 4.Beretta: A400 Xtreme Plus Synthetic product page (checked Sep 26, 2026)
- 5.Sportsman's Warehouse: Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus 12 gauge 3-1/2in 28in specifications (checked Sep 26, 2026)
- 6.Browning: Maxus II Wicked Wing specifications (checked Sep 26, 2026)
- 7.Winchester Repeating Arms: SX4 Waterfowl Hunter Camo specifications (checked Sep 26, 2026)
- 8.Mossberg: 940 Pro Waterfowl product page (checked Sep 26, 2026)
- 9.American Hunter (NRA): Hardware, Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl specifications (accessed Sep 26, 2026)
- 10.Mossberg Journal: Series Overview, 940 Pro Waterfowl (checked Sep 26, 2026)
Specs, materials and warranty terms come from the maker's own pages and manuals (or a named retailer's listing where the maker doesn't publish them), and every one is linked above. Regulations are linked to the agency that writes them. Prices are set by Amazon and change often, so the current number lives on the buy button rather than in the copy. Read the full method.
Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.