Skip to content
Decoy & Drake

Duck & Goose Calls Best picks

Best Duck Calls for Open Water

Big water, wind and birds that never get close. Five calls ranked on the specs that decide whether a duck three hundred yards out hears anything at all.

By Mike M.Updated Published How we score
Open gray bay water under an overcast sky with a distant headland
#ad

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never decides the ranking: the scoring method is published. How we're funded

Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double Reed Duck Call

Top pick

Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double Reed Duck Call

Best overall open-water call

9.5 / 10

The loud end of the double reed world, so you get volume without giving up the forgiving reed, plus published tuning instructions, tune-up kits and a lifetime warranty.

See today's price on the Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double

$29.99 at Amazon · #ad · Price as of November 18, 2026 · Affiliate disclosure for the link to Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double Reed Duck Call

Quick picks

The short answer

#ProductBest forScorePrice
1
Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double Reed Duck Call
Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double Reed Duck Call

The loud end of the double reed world, so you get volume without giving up the forgiving reed, plus published tuning instructions, tune-up kits and a lifetime warranty. It still will not out-reach a good single reed.

Best overall open-water call9.5 / 10$29.99Amazon
2
RNT Daisy Cutter Acrylic Single Reed Duck Call
RNT Daisy Cutter Acrylic Single Reed Duck Call

Acrylic and single reed: the combination that carries furthest in wind, from a maker that publishes tuning services and a lifetime warranty. It punishes sloppy air pressure.

Best single reed for reach9.4 / 10$155.00Amazon
3
No image
Duck Commander Jase Robertson Pro Series Duck Call

A genuine acrylic barrel on a riveted double reed, at a price most acrylics do not reach. Duck Commander publishes no tuning service and no warranty term, and the call is not sold on Amazon.

Best acrylic for the price9.2 / 10

Not sold on Amazon

4
Zink PH-2 Power Hen Polycarbonate Double Reed Duck Call
Zink PH-2 Power Hen Polycarbonate Double Reed Duck Call

Zink builds the Power Hen around big-water volume in polycarbonate. No published tuning service and no warranty term.

Best double reed built for volume9.2 / 10$18.26Amazon
5
Zink Nothing But Green (NBG) Polycarbonate Single Reed Duck Call
Zink Nothing But Green (NBG) Polycarbonate Single Reed Duck Call

A polycarbonate single reed aimed squarely at volume rather than subtlety. The lowest-scoring call here on our published rubric, mostly on support.

Best straightforward loud single9.0 / 10$26.49Amazon

#ad · Prices come live from Amazon, last checked November 18, 2026. Scores are ours, built from published specs, manuals and warranty terms on a rubric we publish. Tap a row for the full write-up.

What open water asks of a call

Open water is the opposite problem to flooded timber. There is nothing to bounce sound off, the wind eats the top end, and the birds you most want to talk to are hundreds of yards out and high. A call that is perfect under a canopy is inaudible on a bay, and the hunter next to you with a loud acrylic will turn birds you never reached.

Volume is a real spec here, and it is the maker's claim rather than a measurement. Nobody in this industry publishes decibels, so on this site the sound score is explicitly the maker's own description and is labelled that way on every card. What you can read reliably is the design: single reeds and harder materials carry further than double reeds and softer ones, and calls marketed for big water are built with more back pressure and a sharper top end.

Range is useless without control. A loud call in cold, tired hands produces loud mistakes, and on open water a bad hail call is visible for a mile: birds flare and keep flaring. The honest sequence is a long, clean hail to turn them, then progressively less as they commit, and silence inside a hundred yards unless they slide. That cadence is in how to blow a duck call.

How to choose an open-water call

Single reed for reach, double reed for insurance. A single reed in acrylic is the furthest-reaching combination on this page and the least forgiving; a loud double reed like the Double Nasty gives up some of that range and gives you back consistency when your hands are numb and the wind is taking your air. If you hunt big water four times a season, take the double. If you live on it, learn the single.

Material earns its money here, unlike in timber. Acrylic is denser and harder than polycarbonate, which is what gives it the sharp, carrying top end. This is the one habitat on this site where paying for acrylic buys a measurable hunting advantage rather than a nicer object, which is why two of the five picks here are acrylic and one of them is the cheapest acrylic we could find. The material comparison is in acrylic vs wood duck calls.

Wind and spray are hard on guts. A call that lives in spray all morning sticks and squeals sooner than one that lives under a canopy. Buck Gardner and RNT both publish tuning support and long warranties; Zink and Duck Commander publish neither for these models, which is the main reason they sit lower on the page despite being perfectly good calls to hunt with.

The spread reaches further than the call does. On big water, decoy numbers, spacing and motion pull birds from distances no call covers. If your open-water hunting is not producing, add decoys and motion before you add volume — see how many duck decoys you need and best motion decoys.

How we scored these

Scored on the same five published metrics as every call on this site: reed system and ease of learning (30%), material and build (20%), tunability and serviceability (20%), the maker's own sound claim (15%) and warranty (15%), published on how we score. These are the same scores these calls carry on best duck calls. Note what that means on a volume page: the rubric rewards ease of use and support rather than loudness alone, so the highest-scoring call here is a double reed. If pure reach is your only criterion, the acrylic single reeds below it are the honest answer, and the page says so rather than bending the scores to fit the headline.

Who should skip all of these

Timber and small-water hunters, where volume flares birds rather than turning them — that list is best duck calls for timber. Beginners, because a loud single reed is the hardest way to learn: best duck calls for beginners. Diver hunters working big water with a large spread, where whistles and silence often beat mallard talk entirely. And anyone hunting geese, who needs a short reed: best goose calls.

In detail

Every pick, in full

1

Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double Reed Duck Call

Best overall open-water call

Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double Reed Duck Call

9.5 / 10

Scored on the duck & goose calls rubric

The loud end of the double reed world, so you get volume without giving up the forgiving reed, plus published tuning instructions, tune-up kits and a lifetime warranty. It still will not out-reach a good single reed.

Reed system & ease of learning (30%)
9.4
Material & build (20%)
9.4
Tunability & serviceability (20%)
9.8
Sound range (maker's claim) (15%)
9.5
Warranty (15%)
9.6

Why we picked it

  • Maker says the Spit-Tech toneboard blows even when wet and won't stick
  • Free retuning for life and a matching reed kit
  • Lifetime warranty on defects, hand-tuned in the USA

Good to know

No specific beginner claim on the product page (Buck Gardner's general guide calls double reeds easy to learn with)

See today's price on the Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double

$29.99 at Amazon · #ad · Price as of November 18, 2026 · Affiliate disclosure for the link to Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double Reed Duck Call

2

RNT Daisy Cutter Acrylic Single Reed Duck Call

Best single reed for reach

RNT Daisy Cutter Acrylic Single Reed Duck Call

9.4 / 10

Scored on the duck & goose calls rubric

Acrylic and single reed: the combination that carries furthest in wind, from a maker that publishes tuning services and a lifetime warranty. It punishes sloppy air pressure.

Reed system & ease of learning (30%)
8.8
Material & build (20%)
9.5
Tunability & serviceability (20%)
9.8
Sound range (maker's claim) (15%)
9.6
Warranty (15%)
9.8

Why we picked it

  • RNT's own description places it above the Short Barrel for volume and drive
  • Reed sets sold, and tuning is free
  • Warranty covers breaks for any reason and transfers with the call

Good to know

Single reed that RNT itself says "may not be for everyone"

See today's price on the RNT Daisy Cutter Acrylic Single Reed

$155.00 at Amazon · #ad · Price as of November 18, 2026 · Affiliate disclosure for the link to RNT Daisy Cutter Acrylic Single Reed Duck Call

3

Duck CommanderNo image

Best acrylic for the price

Duck Commander Jase Robertson Pro Series Duck Call

9.2 / 10

Scored on the duck & goose calls rubric

A genuine acrylic barrel on a riveted double reed, at a price most acrylics do not reach. Duck Commander publishes no tuning service and no warranty term, and the call is not sold on Amazon.

Reed system & ease of learning (30%)
9.6
Material & build (20%)
9.3
Tunability & serviceability (20%)
8.8
Sound range (maker's claim) (15%)
9.5
Warranty (15%)
8.8

Why we picked it

  • Maker's strongest ease-of-use claim in its lineup
  • Double reed pitched for both open water and finishing
  • Sold in acrylic and in Bocote wood barrels

Good to know

No warranty, replacement reeds or tuning service published on duckcommander.com

Not sold on Amazon

Amazon doesn't sell it and we have no tracked retailer that does, so there is no buy link here. The specs above come from Duck Commander's own published page.

4

Zink PH-2 Power Hen Polycarbonate Double Reed Duck Call

Best double reed built for volume

Zink PH-2 Power Hen Polycarbonate Double Reed Duck Call

9.2 / 10

Scored on the duck & goose calls rubric

Zink builds the Power Hen around big-water volume in polycarbonate. No published tuning service and no warranty term.

Reed system & ease of learning (30%)
9.6
Material & build (20%)
9.2
Tunability & serviceability (20%)
8.8
Sound range (maker's claim) (15%)
9.3
Warranty (15%)
8.8

Why we picked it

  • Zink's FAQ names it as the beginner duck call
  • Maker says it avoids the squeak single reeds make when overblown
  • Same calling design as the single-reed PH-1, per Zink

Good to know

No warranty length published

See today's price on the Zink PH-2 Power Hen Polycarbonate

$18.26 at Amazon · #ad · Price as of November 18, 2026 · Affiliate disclosure for the link to Zink PH-2 Power Hen Polycarbonate Double Reed Duck Call

5

Zink Nothing But Green (NBG) Polycarbonate Single Reed Duck Call

Best straightforward loud single

Zink Nothing But Green (NBG) Polycarbonate Single Reed Duck Call

9.0 / 10

Scored on the duck & goose calls rubric

A polycarbonate single reed aimed squarely at volume rather than subtlety. The lowest-scoring call here on our published rubric, mostly on support.

Reed system & ease of learning (30%)
9.2
Material & build (20%)
9.2
Tunability & serviceability (20%)
8.8
Sound range (maker's claim) (15%)
9.1
Warranty (15%)
8.8

Why we picked it

  • Single reed pitched at newcomers
  • Maker says the tone channel is designed not to stick
  • Same calling design as the original PH-1, per Zink

Good to know

Single reeds take more air control to learn than doubles

See today's price on the Zink Nothing But Green (NBG)

$26.49 at Amazon · #ad · Price as of November 18, 2026 · Affiliate disclosure for the link to Zink Nothing But Green (NBG) Polycarbonate Single Reed Duck Call

Decide whether you want reach or reliability, then buy accordingly. For most hunters who visit big water rather than living on it, the Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly is the sensible call: loud for a double reed, forgiving when your hands are cold, and backed by published tuning kits and a lifetime warranty. If reach is the whole point, the RNT Daisy Cutter in acrylic is the standard, with the Duck Commander Jase Pro Series as the cheapest acrylic barrel in the group. Every buy button carries the current Amazon price for that call, except the Jase Pro Series, which Amazon does not stock at all. Then put the range to work properly: long calls to turn birds, less as they commit, and nothing at all inside a hundred yards.

The short version

Our recommendation

Best overall open-water call

9.5 / 10

Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double Reed Duck Call

The loud end of the double reed world, so you get volume without giving up the forgiving reed, plus published tuning instructions, tune-up kits and a lifetime warranty.

See today's price on the Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double

$29.99 at Amazon · #ad · Price as of November 18, 2026 · Affiliate disclosure for the link to Buck Gardner Double Nasty Poly Double Reed Duck Call

Runner-up

9.4 / 10

RNT Daisy Cutter Acrylic Single Reed Duck Call

Acrylic and single reed: the combination that carries furthest in wind, from a maker that publishes tuning services and a lifetime warranty.

See today's price on the RNT Daisy Cutter Acrylic Single Reed

$155.00 at Amazon · #ad · Price as of November 18, 2026 · Affiliate disclosure for the link to RNT Daisy Cutter Acrylic Single Reed Duck Call

How we picked

Why these made the list

Every pick here is researched and compared against the maker's published specs, manuals and warranty terms, scored on a rubric we publish, with each source linked at the bottom of the page.

The weights below are the ones each score was actually computed with, and they hold on every page a product appears on, so the order you see is the order the numbers give. Nobody pays for placement. See every rubric and weight.

Duck & goose calls rubric

Reed system & ease of learning
30%
Material & build
20%
Tunability & serviceability
20%
Sound range (maker's claim)
15%
Warranty
15%

FAQ

Questions hunters ask

What duck call carries furthest on open water?
A single reed in acrylic. The harder material and the single reed together give the sharp top end that survives wind, which is why the RNT Daisy Cutter in acrylic is on this page and why competition callers use that combination. The trade is control: a single reed punishes inconsistent air far more than a double does.
Is a double reed loud enough for big water?
A loud double reed is, within reason. The Buck Gardner Double Nasty and the Zink Power Hen are both built for volume, and they give you most of the reach with a reed system that is far easier to run consistently in cold hands. You give up some of the highest, sharpest end of the range, which matters most on the windiest days.
How often should you call on open water?
Hard at distance, less as they commit, and not at all once they are working. A long hail call is for turning birds that have not seen you; once they are coming, every extra note is a chance to sound wrong. On big water the spread does the close-range convincing, not the call.
Does acrylic really make a difference for open-water calling?
On big water, yes. Acrylic is denser and harder than polycarbonate, which produces the carrying top end you need when wind is stripping sound. This is the one situation on this site where we would tell you the expensive material buys a hunting advantage rather than a nicer-looking call.
What else do you need for open-water duck hunting?
Decoy numbers and motion, mostly. Birds on big water commit to what they can see from a long way off, so spread size, spacing and a spinner or a jerk rig usually change more than any call. Concealment and a boat you can hunt from safely come next.

Related

Update log

What changed

  • First published.

Receipts

Sources

  1. 1.Buck Gardner Calls: Double Nasty Poly product page (checked Sep 19, 2026)
  2. 2.Buck Gardner Calls: Lifetime Warranty (checked Sep 19, 2026)
  3. 3.RNT Calls: Daisy Cutter product page (checked Sep 19, 2026)
  4. 4.RNT Calls: Services, tuning and warranty policy (checked Sep 19, 2026)
  5. 5.Duck Commander: Jase Robertson Pro Series Smoke Acrylic Duck Call product page (checked Sep 19, 2026)
  6. 6.Zink Calls: PH-2 Polycarb product page (checked Sep 19, 2026)
  7. 7.Zink Calls: Nothing But Green product page (checked Sep 19, 2026)

Specs, materials and warranty terms come from the maker's own pages and manuals (or a named retailer's listing where the maker doesn't publish them), and every one is linked above. Regulations are linked to the agency that writes them. Prices are set by Amazon and change often, so the current number lives on the buy button rather than in the copy. Read the full method.

Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.